I want to confess something. I don’t like GodTube. I really am not that big a fan of the site. Don’t get me wrong, there is some good stuff to be found there. But the site as a whole? I just don’t like it.
I understand the reasoning behind creating GodTube. There is a lot of junk and garbage on YouTube (and the myriad of other video-hosting sites on the web). Our Student Ministry program produces a lot of video media and I was forced to withdraw from using at least one video hosting site due to issues over content that was hosted at that site. I can sympathize and agree with the motivations of the creators to set up a place on the web where families can go to knowing that they won’t be bombarded with violence, swearing and overly-sexualized videos and advertising. I stand behind the desire to create such a safe place on the web. But I decided not to utilize GodTube for our video hosting because I think that the execution has been fumbled greatly.
GodTube offers almost exclusively media that can be classified as “Christian.” Much of this media comes across as cheesy, contrived, preachy (not in a good way either) or just downright theologically dangerous (I have discovered a LOT of scare-tactic videos based upon interpretations of Scripture that are flimsy at best and pathetically wrong at worst). And don’t get me started on the apparent copyright infringement of posting music videos from bands and artist that you are not a part of, and technically do not have the rights to distribute. Or full-length videos of bands performing songs on stage when many of the venues these videos are being recorded at stress not to film the entire song. (Yes, I am aware that not every venue has that rule, but I have found several videos that do subvert that rule, specifically some videos from the Alive Festival this year).
Then there is the bickering and backbiting that shows up in the comments below some of the more controversial videos. There is some pretty mean-spirited stuff there, that seems to exist merely to show the world that Christians are the only people who shoot their own wounded. Sure, there is no swearing, but the language is harsh, making judgment calls of someone’s relationship with Christ based upon one comment or one video post, and then arguing with others over something that usually is not an essential. It would actually put a really bad taste in someone’s mouth that was genuinely searching, I feel. Add to that the insane amount of copycats (seriously, 2,370 copies of the Lifehouse Everything skit? It is a creative skit which I really enjoy, and it translates well into many different settings, but have any of the people who have posted their own copy thought through some of the parts of the song that really don’t fit into the song being about God?) and you have a ton of un-originality.
I think that all of these problems add up to one big problem. GodTube (intentionally or not) perpetuates Christian sub-culture, a genre of entertainment that is not something of which I am a fan. Such as in the CCM market, a lot of Christian “entertainment” is a reaction to mainstream culture, coming into existence to give a “Godly alternative” (which is sometimes, but not always, needed), showcasing someone’s talents (that God did not really bless them with anyway) and pointing toward the artist and not toward God (which is the mission of many of these artists), or shoehorning Scripture into interpretations and contexts that it was not written for. It has created a place for Christians to retreat from the rest of the world, where we are demanding that the world come to us in order to be changed and impacted positively, instead of going to the people where they are at to reach them. Sure anyone can come find GodTube, but that is not the point. Not that I am calling for us to dive headlong into the smut that this world has to offer, but it has created one more instance of Christianity withdrawing from the world instead of interacting with it.
Please do not misunderstand. I firmly believe that there is a time and a place for everything. There are videos that GodTube offers that are good for the soul. But as an agent to truly impact the world for Christ, I have a hard time seeing it. I do not desire to discredit GodTube with this post, but there are serious reservations that I have about it. This is not an attack on the creator or the users of GodTube, merely my critique of th product. I welcome your comments, especially if you are a GodTube user and see something that I may have overlooked or seem to have been to harsh on.
Bonus: Check out this article on GodTube from Collide Magazine that is fairly even-handed and does interview the CEO of GodTube.
Recent Comments